Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Historywoman's avatar

I hope you are right, Blair. But Sturgeon wriggles out of every misstep, scandal, mishandling and still her stock is high. I can’t understand why so many people vote for her party. And how we dislodge from these people the lies from the SNP’s mammoth propaganda operation is hard to envisage, given how deeply they are embedded.

Expand full comment
Keith Macdonald's avatar

All good points Blair. Nicola has been stuck for a while and now she has made the wrong move. However it requires skilled and determined opposition to take advantage of that, which can only come from Labour.

The party seems still very reluctant to discuss the constitutional issue in general and to make sharp criticisms of Nicola Sturgeon in particular and I think that has to change.

in addition to the points you make the whole process of a one off referendum is inherently unfair and dishonest. Nicola defended the Brexit process last week because she wants to repeat it but it was in fact the biggest con in British political history.

Her Brexit would outmatch it. Most of the key promises she would make in a referendum campaign would be broken afterwards if she won.

Labour seems to lack the self confidence to go on the attack. We still tend to use even the language of the nationalists, particularly the loaded and misleading term "independence".

In other words there is still all to fight for. Let us get stuck in and we can free Scotland and the UK from the curse of nationalism.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts